Should Gifted Children be Educated Differently?

Homeb
Image by foreversouls via Flickr

Some educators believe that “bright children don’t need any special help; after all, they already have so many things going for them.  The reality is that gifted children’s educational needs arise directly from their strengths; it is precisely because these children are rapid and advanced learners that they need specialized learning opportunities.  They are exceptional children, and they need exceptional services in the same way that children with learning difficulties are exceptional children and need special services and attention.  A Parent’s Guide to Gifted Children, James T. Webb, et.al. (2007).

It is most often up to the parent to educate themselves and advocate for the best educational alternatives for their gifted children.  Each school has different options, from differentiated classrooms, acceleration, grade-skipping, cluster grouping, enrichment in the classroom and in resource rooms, and self-contained full-time gifted programs.  Some states allow children to go to school part-time and to homeschool part-time.  Some families choose to homeschool full-time.

The research that goes into deciding how to educate your gifted child can be overwhelming.  And, you may need to evaluate your choice on an ongoing basis to determine whether your current plan is still working.  

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Social Challenges of Gifted Children

alone
Image by Feuillu via Flickr

Introversion

Although some gifted children are extroverts, more often they are introverted when compared with typical children. When you combine introversion with the frequent lack of fit between gifted children and their age peers ( in terms of interests, skills, knowledge, sensitivity, and intensity), it is not surprising that gifted children, particularly those who are highly gifted, find that they have little in common with their age peers.

Introverts are not likely to approach new children; they are more likely to wait for others to initiate friendships. They need time to observe a situation before joining in and don’t feel the need for as many friends as extroverts do.  (Webb)

Peer Relationships

Every child – gifted or not – wants to feel connected with others. We learn from others how they think or do things, we compare our perceptions of the world with theirs, and we develop a sense of whether we are valued.

Peer relationships are issues for almost every gifted child. Because their interests and behaviors are often unusual and different from age peers, they may find few peers of their own age in their school or neighborhood. Gifted children with unusually high intellectual abilities, intensities, and sensitivities can have even more difficulties finding friends among children their age.  (Webb)

Challenging Values and Traditions

Webb states that gifted children, with their quick minds, logic, and ability to see more than one way to do things, can get into trouble for challenging tradition.

Telling a teacher that she is mistaken breaks tradition; customarily, adults are supposed to know more than children. But since incorrect information bothers gifted children to the core of their being and creates major discomfort, they feel that they must comment to reduce their stress about the situation.

Gifted children’s perfectionism, exacting nature, literal interpretation of events, and concern for truth and justice – especially in those who are auditory-sequential learners – motivate their strong reactions. Older children may be able to handle these situations more diplomatically by talking with the teacher after class rather than challenging her during class, but their reaction is still intense. Their moral sense and need for truth and justice are so strong that they must be addressed in the moment. (Webb)

We strive to find balance in our lives, and our gifted children must do the same. On the one hand, we want them to be creative, because that is where innovation and progress come from. On the other hand, there are times when we want them to respect tradition.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Perfectionism

Perfectionism
Image by Mr Ush via Flickr

Susan Daniels and Michael Peichowski, in Living with Intensity, state that:

Our highly excitable children’s drive for perfect performance is where their intellectual intensity intersects with their emotional development. The field of gifted education is replete with means to accommodate children’s intellectual needs, but a child’s intellectual overexcitability signals a need for more holistic supportive responses form parents and teachers – ones that encompass and nurture their affective and emotional development, self-concept, self-esteem, and self-discipline as well.

Perfectionism in the pursuit of excellence can be a valuable driving force. A healthy pursuit of excellence means doing the best you can with the time and tools you have, and then moving on. Unhealthy perfectionism leaves one continually dissatisfied, as the work is never “good enough.”

A significant number of gifted children, perhaps as many as 20% suffer from perfectionism to the degree that is creates problems for them.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Creative Characteristics of Gifted Children & Homeschool

classSeveral gifted education authors talk about the creative characteristics of gifted children, from divergent thinking, to dealing with complexities to perceptions and learning styles, to having high sensitivities. These characteristics are ideal for the actualization of high creativity.

A gifted child’s view of the world is often non-traditional and divergent; he sees numerous possibilities hidden to others (Webb, Meckstroth, & Tolan, 1982)

Being able to see, hear, feel and experience aspects of life that most people miss is a necessary part of creative production (Dixon, 1983)

High levels of sensitivity may be what drives intellectual giftedness; they allow the child to pick up on vast amounts of input from his environment (Freeman, 1985).

Generally, when children are allowed to learn creatively, we unlock powerful and amazing learning potential (Rivera, 2002)

What does all this mean for me and my children? It means that we do not have to put our noses in books and worksheets to be learning and preparing for the future. We can relax about taking on creative projects that have sometimes felt like an indulgence of our time. We can relax and let the natural curiosity of the children take us to places we wouldn’t have thought of.

I place a much higher emphasis on exploring nature, of nurturing their natural abilities to closely observe differences in detail. I encourage their natural bent of divergent thinking. There is plenty of time for convergent thinking in our studies, and now I encourage, with equal emphasis, plenty of time for divergent thinking.

I attend to their observations of the world, ask more questions about what they see and feel. And, I describe to them the positive side of being highly sensitive and imaginative because of the creativity and beauty they can bring into the world. This is a completely different way of talking to and working with children than in previous generations that preferred to toughen children up and putting them down for pursuing creativity.

I pursue my own creative work  in writing, sewing, photography and whatever arts and crafts projects we try.  I let my kids see what I am doing and discuss it with them. We begin new kinds of art together and struggle through the learning process together. We appreciate the creative works of others, whether art, music, dance or drama. We love to go to plays and concerts. I try to add discussions before and after to increase their appreciation of the beauty of the performance and the hard work that goes into it.

[excerpt from my Minnesota Council for the Gifted and Talented State Conference presentation: Don't Fence Me In - Mastery, Creativity, and Adventure in the Home Education of Bright Children]

Creativity Realized

Creativity is the underpinning, the basement, the foundation that permits talent to be realized. To be creative is necessary in the realization of a fulfilling life…

We are all creative.

Those who are more creative than others have learned to take risks, to value complexity, to see the world, or their own surroundings with naiveté.

What is unnatural and sad is for it to be repressed, suppressed, and stymied through the process of growing up and being educated.

What happens to most of us is that somewhere along the way, and often necessarily, we begin to distrust our creative self. Survival dictates that we subordinate our creative poetic self to a more practical, self. We go along and forget who we are or who we were.

While creativity is the natural propensity of human being-ness, creativity can be enhanced or also stifled. The creative personality can be developed and also thwarted.

Creativity takes certain habits of mind. Creativity is not separate from intelligence or from artistry, but part of the whole.

What is unnatural and sad is for it to be repressed, suppressed, and stymied through the process of growing up and being educated.

What happens to most of us is that somewhere along the way, and often necessarily, we begin to distrust our creative self. Survival dictates that we subordinate our creative poetic self to a more practical, self. We go along and forget who we are or who we were.

Jan Piirto, Ph.D.
Understanding Creativity (2004)

To me that is incredibly sad, and yet very familiar. I’m sure most of us can relate to feeling that the practicality of life and survival have entered into our lives and the creative side has had to take a back seat at times. And, in the past I’m sure we have encountered the cultural realization that some creative endeavors just wouldn’t pay the bills.

However, within the literature and within our society, there is a growing understanding and importance being placed on the integration of creativity skills into whatever field of study you are pursuing.

Creativity does not just refer to the exclusive fields of art, music and the humanities. Creators and innovators are in every field. Design is the ultimate catch phrase for every industry today.

[excerpt from my Minnesota Council for the Gifted and Talented State Conference presentation: Don't Fence Me In - Mastery, Creativity, and Adventure in the Home Education of Bright Children]